# AI-vs-AI Real Battle Smoke Test

This smoke test reruns saved battles where neither side used faction `3` or `4`,
then compares STANDARD-vs-STANDARD winner side with the winner side recorded by
the original Shardok battle. It is intentionally a broad similarity check rather
than an exact replay assertion.

- Checked battles: 31
- Winner-side matches: 31
- Match rate: 100%
- Required match rate: 75%

| Action seq | Factions | Real winner | Sim winner | Real troops | Sim troops |
| ---: | --- | --- | --- | ---: | ---: |
| 306 | 1 vs 2 | attacker | attacker | 1454 vs 0 | 1388 vs 0 |
| 307 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 699 | 0 vs 648 |
| 399 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 1310 | 0 vs 1315 |
| 631 | 1 vs 2 | defender | defender | 0 vs 3766 | 0 vs 3654 |
| 1326 | 9 vs 6 | attacker | attacker | 1715 vs 0 | 1701 vs 0 |
| 2437 | 2 vs 1 | attacker | attacker | 3146 vs 0 | 3247 vs 0 |
| 2584 | 1 vs 2 | defender | defender | 0 vs 2028 | 0 vs 168 |
| 2654 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 335 | 0 vs 467 |
| 3536 | 1 vs 2 | attacker | attacker | 2172 vs 0 | 2528 vs 0 |
| 3701 | 8 vs 2 | defender | defender | 0 vs 2819 | 0 vs 1348 |
| 4298 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 3514 | 0 vs 1977 |
| 4576 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 2028 | 0 vs 1986 |
| 6014 | 2 vs 8 | defender | defender | 0 vs 1942 | 0 vs 2252 |
| 6248 | 7 vs 9 | attacker | attacker | 520 vs 0 | 676 vs 0 |
| 6705 | 1 vs 2 | defender | defender | 0 vs 3316 | 0 vs 535 |
| 7212 | 2 vs 8 | defender | defender | 0 vs 1253 | 0 vs 1273 |
| 8217 | 8 vs 2 | attacker | attacker | 920 vs 0 | 2167 vs 0 |
| 8394 | 2 vs 8 | attacker | attacker | 2449 vs 0 | 3186 vs 0 |
| 9975 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 7420 | 0 vs 7840 |
| 10229 | 5 vs 7 | attacker | attacker | 2135 vs 0 | 1816 vs 0 |
| 10631 | 1 vs 2 | attacker | attacker | 4000 vs 0 | 4000 vs 0 |
| 11011 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 3532 | 0 vs 3658 |
| 11012 | 9 vs 6 | defender | defender | 0 vs 846 | 0 vs 1347 |
| 11297 | 1 vs 2 | attacker | attacker | 2400 vs 0 | 2400 vs 0 |
| 11469 | 5 vs 9 | defender | defender | 0 vs 787 | 0 vs 1489 |
| 11470 | 7 vs 5 | attacker | attacker | 3220 vs 0 | 3425 vs 0 |
| 11565 | 5 vs 7 | defender | defender | 190 vs 3420 | 78 vs 3600 |
| 12136 | 9 vs 7 | attacker | attacker | 1829 vs 0 | 1581 vs 0 |
| 12137 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 1894 | 0 vs 1892 |
| 12765 | 6 vs 9 | defender | defender | 0 vs 1773 | 0 vs 1763 |
| 13752 | 2 vs 1 | defender | defender | 0 vs 943 | 0 vs 932 |
